4.2 Soil amendments and crop nutrition #
Version 2020 – 4.2, Column 1 Soil amendments
Amino acids produced by hydrolysis processes #
Are amino acids produced by hydrolysis processes using sulphuric and phosphoric acid permitted? (422) – 19 Apr 2019
No. When used in crop production, amino acids cannot be produced by hydrolysis using chemicals such as sulphuric and phosphoric acid. See 32.311 4.2 and 4.3 Amino acids b). See 32.311, Table 4.2 – columns 1 & 2, Amino acids.
Testing of ash #
Do all sources of ash have to be tested for heavy metals? (448.1) – 21 June 2019
No. Ash from plant and animal sources is permitted without testing if the source is known and not containing heavy metals. Testing is required when the ash source is unknown or it is known there is a possibility of the ash containing prohibited substances. Testing is to ensure the heavy metal levels are within the limits established in the Guideline for the Beneficial Use of Fertilising Residuals.
Activated biochar #
Is activated biochar permitted? (377.1)
Yes, if the activation is done with permitted substances. Additional requirements, such as the genetic engineering prohibition (1.4 a in 32.310) and annotation restrictions in the substance listing, would need to be addressed.
Can biochar be used as soil substitute in organic containerized greenhouse production systems? (377.2)
No. Biochar cannot be used as a soil substitute as it does not meet the requirements of a soil/growth medium (see 32.310, 7.5.4 (220.127.116.11)). It may be used as a soil amendment as listed in Table 4.2 of PSL.
Blood meal #
In Table 4.2, blood meal is allowed only if sterilized. What does it mean for blood meal to be sterilized? (262)
The Fertilizers Act and Regulations require that fertilizers and supplements not contain any substances likely to be generally detrimental or seriously injurious to domestic animals or public health. Blood meal is defined as “collected blood of slaughtered animals, dried and ground, containing not less than 12% nitrogen”. Blood meal is considered to be “sterilized” if it does not ‘present a risk of harm to human, animal or plant health or the environment’. Commercial manufacturing of blood meal requires a heating/drying phase to meet the definition of sterilization and the requirements of the Fertilizers Act and Regulations.
Calcium chloride #
Is calcium chloride made from the purification of naturally occurring brine allowed under the listing of “Calcium” in Table 4.2? (384)
Yes and No. Yes. Calcium chloride that is purified from naturally occurring brine via evaporation is allowed. Such calcium chloride may be used to address nutrient deficiencies and physiological disorders. No. Other purification processes of naturally occurring brine that involve additional processing steps (e.g.,, bromine removal, sulphur oxide addition, use of strong acid precipitation agents or lime, etc.) render the calcium chloride synthetic according to the COS (see “Mined Minerals, unprocessed” in Table 4.2).
Yes. Calcium chloride that is purified from naturally occurring brine via evaporation is allowed. Such calcium chloride may be used to address nutrient deficiencies and physiological disorders.
Evaluation of extractants #
For substances used in crop production, does the scope of evaluation for extractants require assessment of all materials used or only those that remain in the final product? (443) – 2 December 2019
For substances used in crop production, only extractants that remain in the final product are subject to evaluation, unless extractants are specifically addressed in the substance annotation.
Guano – Dried deposits of guano #
What is meant by “Shall be decomposed, dried deposits” in the Guano 4.2 PSL listing? Does it mean fresh dry deposits from wild bats or birds cannot be used? Or does it mean that the guano must have been decomposed in situ, not dried elsewhere? (434) – 21 June 2019
Wild bat and seabird guano must decompose at the site of deposits, not be dried elsewhere, and have been in place for a sufficient time to decompose and dry before collection. Collection shall not impact an active colony.
Multi-ingredient fertilizer- non-organic oilseed meal #
When used in a multi-ingredient fertilizer, is the use of non-organic oilseed meal subject to the commercial availability restriction? (387)
Yes. Even when used as a component of a multi-ingredient fertilizer a commercial availability search is required as per the annotation for “Oilseed meals” (Table 4.2). Therefore, an operator wishing to use this fertilizer blend would need to perform a commercial availability search for a fertilizer blend that is fully compliant before using this product.
Definition of wastes from crops #
Under “Plants and plant by-products” in PSL 4.2, does the restriction “Wastes from crops that have been treated or produced with prohibited substances may be used as composting feedstocks” apply only to wastes from crops or does it apply to all plant materials? What is the definition of “wastes from crops”? (388)
“Wastes from crops” is referring to vegetal matter (plant and plant waste) from any source.
Compost feedstocks #
With regard to materials other than livestock manure, are all the materials used to make compost required to be free from toxins, or can it be determined that some or all toxins present in the compost feedstock will break down and be purified during the composting process? (76)
The notes in PSL Table 4.2 (32.311) under the headings “Compost from off-farm sources”, “Compost produced on the farm” and “Compost Feedstocks” give extensive instruction as to what is required, permitted or prohibited in the production of compost. The underlying assumption is that the composting process is capable of degrading some contaminants that are present in the original material. When materials are used that may contain persistent prohibited substances, it is the responsibility of the operator to document or “prove” the process of degradation. The notation allows for two possible methods; 1) analysis of the final composted material or 2) reference to scientific literature which establishes the common degradation of contaminants during the composting process. In the case of materials obtained from an urban setting, e.g., leaves or yard waste; it should be assumed that persistent chemicals, including pesticides are present and due diligence as outlined above should be practiced. It is the CB’s responsibility to assess the risk and require documentation specific to each situation.
What documentation is required to substantiate common degradation of contaminants during the composting process as implied in Table 4.2 “compost feedstocks”? (133)
Acceptable documentation would consist of published academic studies. Claims made by manufacturers must be verified by independent research. Operators also have the option of analysis of the final product to confirm that no contaminants persist.
If GE plants are used in the production of compost, can that compost be used to fertilize organic farms? We are concerned with families who buy conventional food and add the household waste to their compost. (129)
The presence of GE plant material is strongly discouraged, but the possibility of use as compost feedstock is not eliminated. See Table 4.2, 32.311 Plant and Plant by-products:
“Wastes from crops that have been treated or produced with prohibited substances may be used as composting feedstocks”.
However compost is subject to the following restrictions under Compost feedstocks: “When evidence indicates that composting feedstocks may contain a substance prohibited by 1.4/1.5 of CAN/CGSB 32.310 known to be persistent in compost, documentation or testing of the final product may be required.”
Human waste in compost #
Can urine from unmedicated individuals be added into compost which is used in organic certified production? (401)
No. Human waste is not listed as a permitted compost feedstock. See Compost feedstocks, Table 4.2.
Biodegradable bags as compost feedstocks #
Can residential food waste collected in biodegradable bags be used as a compost feedstock? (302)
Yes, as long as the biodegradable bags and the residential food waste decompose effectively during the composting process. If applicable, the absence of petrochemical residues may need to be confirmed by testing. See Table 4.2, column 1, Composting feedstocks.
Coloured ink in compost feedstock #
If tests demonstrate acceptable levels of heavy metals, foreign matter and human pathogens, as specified in Guidelines for Compost Quality, is compost made from Municipal Source Separated Organic (SSO) household waste, which is composed mainly of vegetal and animal origin but could contain some coloured newsprint (added to household containers to absorb moisture and odors), and possibly other prohibited substances, permitted? (470) – 17 February 2020
No. Regardless of whether testing indicates acceptable levels of heavy metals, finished compost must conform to the compost feed stocks annotation, which, for example, prohibits paper with coloured ink other than yard waste bags. See 32.311 table 4.2 Compost feedstocks.
Testing of compost used as ingredient #
When compost is used as an ingredient in a blended fertilizer product, should the analysis for heavy metals, foreign matter, and pathogens occur on the compost ingredient prior to blending or on the final blended fertilizer? (334)
Compost must meet the required specifications whether it is applied directly to the soil or blended with other ingredients. In the case of a blended product, the compost analysis shall be performed prior to blending with other ingredients.
Forestry by-products as compost feedstocks #
Can bark or forestry by-products be used as a compost feedstock? (461.1) – 17 February 2020
Yes. Forestry by-products can be used as compost feedstocks providing it can be demonstrated they do not contain a substance prohibited by 1.4 of CAN/CGSB-32.310 known to be persistent in compost. See Table 4.2 Compost Feedstocks.
Heavy metal analysis of off-farm sourced compost #
Is a heavy metal analysis required for each individual compost ingredient used in the manufacture of off-farm sourced compost? (353)
“No. It is not necessary to test each ingredient of a compost before the composting process. Heavy metal analysis is required at the end of the composting process, before it is blended with any other substances, such as potting mixes, minerals, other composts, etc. See Compost from off-farm sources,Table 4.2.
No. It is not necessary to test each ingredient of a compost before the composting process. Heavy metal analysis is required at the end of the composting process. See Compost from off-farm sources, Table 4.2, column 1.
Expanded perlite #
Is expanded perlite permitted under the listing of ‘Clay’ on Table 4.2? (335)
Yes.The physical expansion of perlite during its manufacturing is permitted as the process does not change the molecular structure of the substance.
Fish products – Stabilization
The manufacturer of a fish-based soil and plant fertilizer would like to stabilize the product by reducing the pH below 3.5. Is this allowable? (114)
Yes. As long as the amount used is not in excess of what is needed to stabilize the product. See Fish meal, fish powder, fish wastes, hydrolysate, emulsions and solubles listing in PSL Table 4.2. See Fish products, Table 4.2, column 1 of PSL.
Fish & kelp products – Preservative #
Can potassium sorbate be used as a preservative in kelp and fish products used as fertilizers? (110.1)
Potassium sorbate can be used as a preservative in kelp and fish fertilizers provided it meets the non-synthetic definition in 3.39. The origin and usage annotations for both the “Aquatic plants and aquatic plant products” and the “Fish meal, fish powder, fish wastes, hydrolysate, emulsions and soluble” listings, in PSL Table 4.2, prohibit synthetic preservatives.
Potassium sorbate can be used as a preservative in water-extracted kelp-based fertilizers as potassium sorbate is specifically mentioned in the ‘Aquatic plants and aquatic plant products’ annotation in PSL Table 4.2. But it cannot be used in fish-based fertilizers as it is not listed in ‘Fish products’ annotation.
Definition of fish farm waste #
What is the definition of “fish farm wastes” used in the listing of “Fish meal, fish powder, fish waste, hydrosylate, emulsions and solubles” (Fish products) in Table 4.2? Does it need to be composted? (333)
Fish farm wastes consist of sludge and mortal remains (fish, bones, scraps, carcasses, etc.) collected at the fish farm. Such wastes cannot be used raw; it must be composted or processed before use. Manufactured fish by-products, such as processed fish meals or liquid fish fertilizers made with farmed fish and/or fish farm wastes, do not have to be composted before use.
Lactic acid produced by fermentation and extraction #
Is lactic acid produced by fermentation and extraction allowed under the Canadian Organic Standards? Is that lactic acid considered to be synthetic? (331)
UNDER REVIEW BY THE STANDARDS INTERPRETATION COMMITTEE
Lactic acid produced by fermentation and extraction is permitted. Extraction processes must use permitted extractants (See Extractants, Table 4.2 and 4.3 and Extraction solvents, carriers and precipitation aids, Table 6.3). Lactic acid produced by fermentation and extraction is non-synthetic under the Canadian Organic Standards. Requirements with regard to substrates/growth media must be met. Chemical processes used to purify and/or extract substances are permitted as long as they do not create new molecules or involve processes specifically prohibited by the standard. See Synthetic substance, 3.65, 32.310.
Gibberellic acid produced by fermentation and extraction #
Is gibberellic acid produced by fermentation and extraction allowed under the Canadian Organic Standards? Is that gibberellic acid considered to be synthetic? (332)
Gibberellic acid produced by fermentation and extraction is permitted. Extraction processes must use permitted extractants. See Extractants,Tables 4.2 and 4.3. Gibberellic acid produced by fermentation and extraction is considered to be non-synthetic under the Canadian Organic Standards. Requirements with regard to substrates/growth media must be met. Chemical processes used to purify and/or extract substances are permitted as long as they do not create new molecules or involve processes specifically prohibited by the standard. See synthetic substance, 3.65 (32.310).
Gibberellic acid produced by fermentation and extraction is permitted. Classifying the synthetic / non-synthetic is no longer required as of the 2020 revision of the standard. Confirmation is needed to ensure the gibberellic acid is derived from biological materials.
Minerals – Flotation reagents #
Does the use of flotation reagents in extraction & purification of mined minerals render the product prohibited? Is a producer required to demonstrate the absence of flotation reagents in the final product? (189)
Minerals which have been extracted using flotation reagents that are not intended to form part of the mineral substance are allowed. Given that flotation reagents are removed and reused by the mining industry, the operator is not required to prove the purity of the final product.
About fused minerals #
Are fused mineral fertilizers (created by heating and blending minerals) compliant to COR? (464) -17 February 2020
No. Unless specifically listed in the PSL, minerals that have undergone such a change are not permitted.
Microbial fertilizers and soil amendments #
What are the requirements for substrates used to create microbial fertilizers or microbial soil amendments? (167.2)
The requirements for feedstock used to create microbial soil amendments are distinct for two separate groups of products; i) microbial products containing no residue of the substrate: for these, the feedstock should be non-GE if commercially available. ii) products in which the microbial is delivered along with a remnant of the feedstock: here feedstock materials must be listed on PSL Tables 4.2 or 4.3 and comply with any annotations. (see PSL 4.13)
As of the 2020 standard, microbial fertilizers and microbial soil amendments may not be derived from municipal sewage sludge (see ‘Microorganisms and microbial products’ PSL 4.2). In addition, if the product contains the substrate: the feedstock materials must be listed on PSL Table 4.2 and comply with any annotations (4.1.3 a). Or, if they do not contain the substrate, the substrate should be non-GE if commercially available (4.1.3 b).
If a blended, multi-ingredient soil amendment contains non-organic molasses, can it be used in organic production? (188)
No. Organic molasses is required (see Molasses PSL Table 4.2)
Non-organic spent brewers’ grains as amendment #
Can non-organic spent brewers’ grains be used as a soil amendment? As a compost feedstock? (323)
To be acceptable for use as a soil amendment, non-organic spent brewers’ grains must be non-GE and any non-agricultural substances added during the brewing process must be listed on Table 4.2 of 32.311 and comply with 1.4 a and d (with 1.4 a and 1.5 a) of 32.310. For example, diammonium phosphate (DAP) added during the brewing process would render spent brewers’ grains non-compliant for use as a soil amendment in organic production. Non-organic spent brewers’ grains from GE sources are an acceptable composting feedstock, as GE residues do not persist after the thermophilic stage of the composting process. See Compost feedstocks in Table 4.2.
Corn steep liquor as an amendment #
Is non-organic corn steep liquor allowed as a soil amendment/fertilizer in organic production? (503) – 18 Dec 2020
No. However, organic corn steep liquor would be permitted. Refer to SIC Q&A 60a for further insight.
Paper mill sludge #
Can paper mill sludge be used on organic farms? (294)
No. Sludge from paper mills is not listed in CAN/CGSB-32.311and is therefore not permitted for use on organic farms (32.310 1.4 d). Any synthetic extractants, solvents or additives used when generating plant by-products are prohibited, except as specified in the annotations of substances listed on Table 4.2.
Sludge from standard paper mills contains substances not listed in CAN/CGSB-32.311 and is therefore not permitted for use on organic farms (32.310 1.5 a). If all extractants, solvents or additives (e.g., glues, preservatives, etc.) used when generating the paper are covered by the ‘Extractants’ or the ‘Plants and plant by-products’ listings in PSL 4.2 – column 1, then the sludge would be permitted.
Potassium sulphate #
Can potassium sulphate which has not been mined, but manufactured by combining mined potassium chloride, mined sodium sulphate and water, be used as a soil amendment in accordance with the PSL? (166)
Yes. Potassium sulphate produced by combining two mined minerals is permitted (see d, Potassium sulphate, under the Potassium listing – PSL, Table 4.2); however, in general, mined minerals may not be processed or fortified with synthetic chemicals except where specifically permitted in the annotation. Potassium sulphates made using reactants such as sulfuric acid or ammonia are prohibited. (see “Mined Minerals, unprocessed PSL” Table 4.2).
Yes. Potassium sulphate produced from combining mined minerals using ion exchange is permitted (see Potassium d), PSL, Table 4.2);. Potassium sulphates made using sulphuric acid as a reactant are prohibited.
Potassium nitrate not allowed #
Can potassium nitrate be an allowed fertilizer in organic production, if the nitrogen was derived from compliant anaerobic digestate? (502) – 18 Dec 2020
No. It no longer is a digestate, and neither is it listed in the Potassium listing in PSL, Table 4.2.
Soap in soil amendment #
Can a compliant soil amendment contain soap? (397)
No. Soil amendments, such as compost, manure, etc., may not contain soaps as they are restricted to Production aids in PSL, Table 4.3 (Table 4.2, column 2). See Soaps, PSL, 4.2, column 2.
Fish products – Fatty acids #
If fatty acids are allowed in organic production systems as a pesticide (see soaps, PSL 4.3), are fatty acids allowable in fish and aquatic plant products used as organic fertilizers? (110.1)
Fatty acids from plant and animal sources are allowed in fish and aquatic plant products used as organic fertilizers. They are not allowed if they are from synthetic sources, such as fatty acids extracted using hexane. For a synthetic to be allowed as an ingredient in an organic fertilizer, the substance must be included on the PSL Table 4.2 or 4.3.
If fatty acids are allowed in organic production systems as a pesticide (see Soaps, PSL Table 4.2 – column 2), are fatty acids allowable in fish and aquatic plant products used as organic fertilizers? (110b)
No. Fatty acids, aka soaps, derived from plant and animal sources are not allowed in aquatic plant products or fish products used as fertilizers applied to the soil, as the Soap listing restricts the use of soap to production aids such as pesticide applications or foliar nutrient sprays. See Soaps, PSL, Table 4.2, column 2 and Aquatic plants and aquatic plant products, PSL, Table 4.2, column 1.
Is sugar allowed as a soil amendment? (60.1)
Organic sugar only can be used as a soil amendment. An organic substance does not have to be listed on table 4.2, column 1, to be allowed as a soil amendment.
Sulphuric acid #
Please outline the application for the use of sulphuric acid for crops (98) (50)
Sulphuric acid cannot be used to manufacture calcium sulphate (gypsum), or potassium sulphate (see individual listings in PSL Table 4.2). Nor can it used as a pH buffer (see “pH buffer” in PSL Table 4.2 & 4.3) except in fish products but only if vinegar, non-synthetic citric acid and phosphoric acid are ineffective. (see “Fish meal, fish powder, fish waste, hydrolysate, emulsions and solubles).
Sulphuric acid cannot be used to manufacture calcium sulphate (gypsum), or potassium sulphate (see individual listings in PSL Table 4.2 – column 1). Sulphuric acid may be used to stabilize fish products but only if vinegar, citric acid, phosphoric acid are ineffective. See Fish products, Table 4.2).
Additives in soil amendments #
Can fertilizers used as soil amendment in organic production be supplemented with synthetic substances? (167.1)
No. If a compliant soil amendment is enhanced or changed using additional substances, those substances must appear on Table 4.2 in order for the resulting soil amendment to be compliant.
Can soil amendments be supplemented with non-listed non-organic substances? (167.1)
No. If a compliant soil amendment is enhanced or changed using additional non-organic substances, those substances must appear on Table 4.2 – column 1 and comply with any annotation restrictions in the applicable substances’ listings.
Non-synthetic mineral fertilizers in ion-exchange systems #
Does running a non-synthetic mineral fertilizer through an ion-exchange system render the mineral fertilizer synthetic? (365)
Yes. The use of an ion exchange system involves chemical reactions and unless specifically permitted by the PSL (Table 4.2) is prohibited. The word “combining” in PSL table 4.2 for “potassium sulphate” allows potassium sulphate that has gone through an ion-exchange system
Version 2020 This QA will be deleted.
Tractor exhaust #
Is tractor exhaust, injected into the soil, acceptable under the standard? (32)
Tractor exhaust may be injected into the soil only if all the components of the tractor exhaust comply with the standard and PSL. This means 100% pure biodiesel exhaust would be acceptable while exhaust generated by a petroleum gas engine would not.
Limestone from sugar processing #
Under Table 4.2, is “limestone from sugar processing” allowed without evaluating the manufacturing process? (306)
Lime from sugar processing and mined calcium carbonate are acceptable sources. Review of the manufacturing process is not required.
Is “lime from sugar processing” in the annotation to Calcium, in table 4.2, column 1, allowed without evaluating the manufacturing process? (306)
Yes. Review of the manufacturing process is not required.
Rock phosphate #
The listing for rock phosphate in table 4.2 restricts cadmium levels to 90 mg/kg P2O5. Is that to be calculated on the total P2O5 or the available P2O5? (305)
The amount of P2O5 used in the calculation is the total amount, not the available amount.
Wool as mulch #
Can conventional wool be used as mulch? (324)
Yes. Even though wool is not specifically mentioned in the mulch listing in Table 4.3, wool from either organic or non-organic operations could be used as a mulch.
4.3 Crop Production Aids and Materials #
Version 2020 – 4.2 Column 2 – Crop Production Aids and Materials #
Acetic acid #
Can acetic acid solution be used as a weed control product in organic production? (172)
Yes. Non-synthetic sources of acetic acid may be used for weed control. See Acetic acid, PSL, Table 4.3).
Yes. Acetic acid not made from petrochemicals may be used for weed control. See Acetic acid, Table 4.2, column 2, PSL.
Use of antibiotics in orchards #
Is streptomycin allowed in apple production to control fire blight? (311)
No. The amended standard published MAR 2018 clarifies that antibiotics, including streptomycin, are prohibited in crop production. See Biological organisms, 32.311, Table 4.3 (Table 4.2).
Citric acid #
Can citric acid be used as a pH adjuster during the extraction of Fulvic Acid? (248)
Yes. Citric acid would be acceptable as an extractant. See Humates, humic acid and fulvic acid a), Extractants e) and Citric acid in Table 4.2 of PSL.
Combined formulations #
Can a pesticide and a fertilizer be combined under the COR? (110.3)
Yes. An operator wishing to use a pesticide in a fertilizer formulation must ensure that the requirements of 32.310 5.6.1 and 5.6.2 are fulfilled. Pest control substances listed on the PSL Table 4.3 can only be used when other cultural approaches fail and require the documented presence of the pest organism. Fertilizer applications must be applied according to the plant’s requirements based upon the plant’s growth stage.
Yes. A pesticide listed in the Table 4.2, column 2 of the PSL can be combined with a fertilizer providing the requirements in 5.6.1 and 5.6.2 in 32.310 are fulfilled and the nutrient load does not exceed the limits of the nutrient management plan. See 3.46 in 32.310.
Formulants – Soil amendments & crop production aids #
Are the restrictions in the formulant listings in Table 4.2 & 4.3 (Table 4.2) only applicable when formulants are specifically mentioned in an annotation? Or do the annotations for formulants apply whenever a substance contains a formulant? Case in point, may repellents contain formulants?(483) – 29 April 2020
The formulant listings apply whenever a substance contains a formulant unless a specific derogation is identified in an annotation. In the case of repellents: PMRA List 4 formulants are allowed in Repellents listed in Table 4.3 (Table 4.2).
Non-complying formulants in pesticides #
What is the status of a crop on which a pesticide was applied containing an active ingredient listed in Table 4.3 (Table 4.2) of the PSL but also a formulant from List 3 of PMRA? (326.1)
In most cases the crop cannot be certified because (with the exception of List 3 formulants in passive pheromone dispensers) only formulants from Lists 4a and 4b of PMRA may be used in pesticides allowed by Table 4.3 (Table 4.2, column 2). However, if the List 3 formulant is covered by a different substance listing in Table 4.3 (Table 4.2, column 2) (e.g., essential oils and aloe vera gel under Plant extracts, soap under Soaps, etc.) or Table 4.2, column 1, (talc under Mined minerals, etc.), the crop could be certified.
Will a 36-month transition period be required for the land where the pesticide described in 326a was applied? (326.2)
A 36-month transition will not be required if the List 3 formulant is a permitted substance. See Formulants used in crop production aids, Table 4.3 or 4.2. (Table 4.2).
Insecticidal soaps #
Can insecticidal soaps that contain isopropyl alcohol, in addition to the fatty acids derived from animal or vegetable oils, be used in organic production? (75)
Yes, insecticidal soaps containing isopropyl alcohol can be used since isopropyl alcohol (1-Propanol) is a formulant listed in List of formulants 4B of PMRA. See Formulants used in crop production aids, Table 4.2.
Kaolin clay #
Is calcined kaolin clay a permitted substance under Canadian Organic Standards? (223)
Yes. Calcined kaolin clay is allowed, but only if no synthetic chemicals were used or added during the calcination process. (See Kaolin clay PSL Table 4.3)
Version 2020 This QA will be removed as ‘calcined’ has been added to the annotation relating to Kaolin clay.
Calcination of kaolin #
Is calcined kaolin allowed as a crop production aid (Table 4.3) if synthetic chemicals are added prior to calcination, such as flocculating agents, bleaching agents, and fluxes? (386)
Kaolin clay, per the annotation in 4.3, cannot be processed or fortified with synthetic chemicals unless they are listed in Table 4.2. See Mined Minerals, unprocessed in Table 4.2.
Version 2020 This QA will be removed as ‘Shall not be processed’ has been added to the annotation relating to Kaolin clay.
Is the delivery of pheromones confined to passive dispensers or is spraying application allowed? (93)
Yes. The annotation for pheromones limits the delivery to traps or passive dispensers. Spraying applications are prohibited. See Pheromones and other semiochemicals in PSL, Table 4.3.
Yes. All sources are permitted. For pest control.
Hay preservatives with prohibited substances in an organic field #
If a hay preservative containing prohibited substances is applied while baling, and the hay is being sold as non-organic, does the field lose its organic status? (445) – 21 June 2019
Yes. The field would lose organic status as there is no means to ensure the field will not become contaminated to some degree. Only hay preservatives approved for organic use or those containing active ingredients listed in 4.2, 4.3 & 5.2 (4.2 & 5.2) are permitted.
Acceptable substances in biodegradable mulches #
Can biodegradable mulches contain substances listed in PSL 4.2 or 4.3 (PSL 4.2)? (371.1)
If yes, does the annotations for those substances listed in Tables 4.2 and 4.3 of the PSL (Table 4.2 of the PSL) have to be addressed? (371.2)
Annotation restrictions apply even if substances are used as components of a biodegradable mulching material. For example, if embedding micronutrients into the material, the annotation for micronutrients must be addressed.
Processes in the manufacturing of mulches #
Could a biobased film become non-compliant because of the manufacturing process that would disqualify it from being used on organic farms? (284)
No. Biobased biodegradable mulches must meet the requirements listed in Table 4.3 of the PSL and have been evaluated according to the criteria specified in Clause 10.3, Table 8. These criteria give preference to non-synthetic substances and consider the environmental impact of manufacture but do not specify any current restrictions on manufacturing processes.
No. The manufacturing of a biobased biodegradable mulch does not come into scope when a CB reviews a product for use. Biobased biodegradable mulches must meet the requirements listed in Table 4.2 of the PSL.
Plastic mulch removal #
Are bioplastic mulches, made from corn, accepted as “biodegradable films” that can be left to decompose in the soil? (79, 253)
To be acceptable as biodegradable and left to decompose in the soil, a bioplastic mulch made from corn:
1) cannot be made using GE plant material;
2) cannot contain substances such as biodegradable polymers, Carbon Black from GE or petroleum.
Mulches containing biodegradable polymers and Carbon Black from GE or petroleum sources which were considered to be compliant in 2014 can be used and left in fields without removal as a temporary exemption until January 1, 2017 (see Mulches PSL Table 4.3 in 311 and the definition of biodegradable in 3.10 in 32.310).
To be acceptable as biodegradable and left to decompose in the soil, a bioplastic mulch made from corn:
1) cannot be made using GE plant material;
2) cannot contain substances such as biodegradable polymers, Carbon Black from GE or petroleum.
3) must meet the biodegradable criteria specified in biodegradable definition (3.11 in 32.310).
Kraft lignin in biodegradable planting containers #
Is Kraft lignin allowed as an ingredient in biodegradable planting containers that are left in the soil to decompose? (352)
Yes. Most papers are produced using the Kraft process. If all other ingredients are listed in Table 4.2, planting containers that contain Kraft lignin can be left to decompose in soil. See Table 4.3 (Table 4.2, column 2) Biodegradable plant containers.
Microbial substrates #
May a bacteria for use as an organic crop production aid be produced using prohibited materials in the substrate? (141)
PSL Table 4.3 (4.2) allows the use of “Biological organisms”, which includes bacteria, providing they are not genetically engineered.
The requirements for the substrate on or in which they are propagated fall into two distinct categories;
i) microbial products containing no residue of the substrate: for these, the substrate feedstocks should be non-GE if commercially available.
ii) products in which the microbial is delivered along with a remnant of the substrate: here feedstock materials must be listed on PSL Tables 4.2 or 4.3 (Table 4.2, PSL) and comply with any annotations. See PSL 4.1.3.
Neem oil #
Can neem oil be used to treat powdery mildew in cucumbers? (268)
Registered neem based pesticides can be used as a Crop Production Aid based on the listing in Table 4.3 (Table 4.2, column 2) of the PSL “Botanical Pesticides”, with restrictions noted in the “Origin and Usage” column. Formulants included in these pesticides also have to comply with PSL requirements.
Magnesium lignosulphate #
Is Magnesium lignosulphate allowed under the listing of lignin sulphonates in Table 4.3 of the Permitted Substances List? (289)
Lignin sulphonates, including magnesium lignosulphate, are allowed as chelating agents for micronutrients, formulant ingredients or dust suppressants.
Lignin forms such as lignosulphonic acid, calcium lignosulphonate, magnesium lignosulphonate, sodium lignin and sodium lignosulphonate are permitted.
Sulphonates manufactured with non-listed substances #
Are lignin sulphonates manufactured with non-listed substances (e.g., calcium bisulphate) permitted? (355)
All lignin sulphonates, except ammonium lignin sulphonates, are allowed, as crop production aids, if used as chelating agents, formulants, or as dust suppressants. See Lignin sulphonates,’ Table 4.3, (Table 4.2) and 4.1.1 b) of PSL.
Is Rotenone allowed for use in organic production? (308)
Rotenone is a substance that qualifies as botanical pesticides. However, in countries such as Canada, where rotenone products are no longer registered for agricultural use, they cannot be used for organic production.
Water is listed as permissible. Can you please confirm if seawater can be used in crop production? (23)
Yes. Table 4.3 (Table 4.2, column 2) of the PSL allows for Water which would include seawater to be used as a crop production aid.
Sprout inhibitor – Ethylene #
Is the use of ethylene as a sprout inhibitor for onions and potatoes admissible? (43)
No. The use of ethylene is restricted to tropical fruit ripening and citrus degreening. See PSL Table 8.4.
Yes and no. The use of ethylene is permitted for potato sprout control, but not onions. See Table 8.3 of PSL.
Structural PVC tubing #
Can PVC tubing be used as structural material to hold insect nets? (136)
Yes. PVC tubing may be used. The prohibition of poly vinyl chloride for mulches and row covers does not apply to the structural material.
Transplant containers #
If paper containers are placed in the ground as transplant containers and allowed to decompose, what are the requirements for the paper? (187)
The requirements are the same as for mulch (see Q&A 79). No glossy paper or coloured ink. Must be 100% biodegradable derived from bio-based sources to be left to decompose in the ground.
Weed barriers #
Could a woven polypropylene weed barrier cloth be left in place for 3-5 years in an orchard or vineyard? (347.1)
Yes, it can be left in place as long as it doesn’t start to degrade.
Can the same thing be done with 100% coconut fibre mats? (347.2)
If the coconut fibre mats do not contain any prohibited materials, they can be used and left to degrade in place.